- Julia Delacruz (Heiress Slayer)
- Jefferson Andrews (Former Initiative Agent)
- Alexa Cain (Slayer in Training to be used with Annie Clark)
- Ike Clanton (Gunslinger)
- Chase Dakota (Leader of the Devil's Angels)
- Dysis (Slayer)
- Douglas Haven (Narcotics Cop)
- Isabella (Souled Vampire)
- Penny (Slayer)
- Rhiannon (Singer Slayer)
- Artemis (Awakened Goddess)
- Todd Grissom (Inquisitive Jock)
- Abby Hargrove (Slayer in Training)
- Morrissa (Sunnydale Witch from Season 4)
- Mateo (Reluctant Psychic)
- Brayden "Bray" Richards (Demon Hunter)
- Juanita Rodriguez (Gang Leader)
- AnnaBella Rumbaldi (Slayer)
- Darby Shaw (Psychic Reporter)